服务支持

12

2013

-

07

The function of the safety barrier

Currently, the main types of safety barriers in use are resistive, Zener, relay-amplified, and isolated barriers, with Zener and isolated barriers being the most widely applied. Zener Safety Barrier The Zener safety barrier operates on the reverse breakdown (conducting) characteristic of Zener diodes. (1) When the supply voltage is normal—typically rated at 24 V and not exceeding 28 V—the Zener diodes VDW1 and VDW2 remain non-conducting, and the loop current is determined by the transmitter within the 4–20 mA range. In the event of a short-circuit fault on-site, the presence of resistor R limits the short-circuit current to below the safe rated value, thereby ensuring safety. (2) When the barrier terminal voltage V1 exceeds the safe rated voltage V0 but remains below the discharge voltage Var of the spark gap—that is, V0 ≤ V1 ≤ Var—the Zener diodes break down (conduct), causing the current through fuse F1 to increase. Once this current rises above 125 mA, the fast-acting fuse F1 blows first (within microseconds), instantly isolating the potentially hazardous high voltage from the field. Prior to F1 blowing, the voltage-regulating action of VDW1 and VDW2 continues to maintain safety in the hazardous area. (3) When V1 reaches or exceeds Var, the spark gap immediately discharges, reducing the terminal voltage to a very low level (below 10–20 V). At this point, the current through fuse F2 rises rapidly; when it reaches 1 A, F2 blows, cutting off the hazardous high voltage and safeguarding production safety. Under normal operating conditions, thanks to the current-limiting effect of resistor R and the voltage-regulating function of the Zener diodes, fluctuations in current and voltage on the hazardous side are effectively constrained, so fuses F1 and F2 do not need to blow frequently. Zener safety barriers are compact, lightweight, highly accurate, versatile, and more affordable than isolated barriers; moreover, they can achieve very high explosion-proof ratings. However, the key component of such barriers—the fast-acting fuse—is extremely difficult to manufacture, with stringent requirements for both process technology and materials. The fuse must blow at a rate at least ten times faster than the Zener diode could burn out. Zener safety barriers require a separate intrinsically safe grounding system. Isolated Safety Barrier This type employs a circuit architecture that electrically isolates the input, output, and power supply from one another while simultaneously meeting the energy-limiting requirements of intrinsic safety. Compared with Zener barriers, although slightly more expensive, its other outstanding advantages bring greater benefits to users: 1. Because of the three-way isolation, no system grounding line is required, greatly simplifying design and on-site installation. 2. Instrumentation requirements in hazardous areas are significantly reduced, eliminating the need for intrinsically safe instruments on site. 3. Since signal lines do not share a common ground, the stability and anti-interference capability of detection and control loop signals are greatly enhanced, thereby improving the overall system reliability. 4. Isolated safety barriers offer superior input-signal processing capabilities, able to accept and handle thermocouple, resistance thermometer, and frequency signals—functions that Zener barriers cannot perform. 5. Isolated safety barriers can output two mutually isolated signals, allowing two devices powered by the same signal source to operate without mutual interference, while also enhancing the electrical safety insulation between the connected devices. Therefore, after comparing the characteristics and performance of Zener and isolated safety barriers, it is evident that isolated barriers have distinct advantages and broader applications. Although their price is slightly higher than that of Zener barriers, when considering design, construction, installation, commissioning, and maintenance costs, their total cost may actually be lower. On demanding project sites, isolated safety barriers are almost invariably used as the primary intrinsically safe explosion-proof instrumentation, gradually replacing Zener barriers and enjoying increasingly widespread application in the field of safety and explosion protection.


Currently, the main types of safety barriers in use are resistive, Zener, relay-amplified, and isolated barriers, with Zener and isolated barriers being the most widely applied.
Zener-type safety barrier
A Zener-type safety barrier operates based on the reverse breakdown (turn-on) characteristic of a Zener diode.
(1) When the supply voltage is normal, with a rated value of 24 V and a maximum of 28 V, the Zener diodes VDW1 and VDW2 are non-conducting, and the loop current is determined by the transmitter within the 4–20 mA range. In the event of a short-circuit fault on-site, the presence of resistor R limits the short-circuit current to below the safe rated value, thereby ensuring safety.
(2) When the gate voltage V1 is higher than the safe rated voltage V0 but lower than the discharge voltage Var of the gas discharge tube—i.e., V0 ≤ V1 ≤ Var—the Zener diode breaks down (turns on), causing the current through F1 to increase. Once this current rises above 125 mA, the fast-acting fuse F1 blows first (within microseconds), immediately isolating the high voltage that could cause an accident from the field. Prior to F1 blowing, the voltage-regulating function of VDW1 and VDW2 continues to ensure safety in hazardous areas.
(3) When V1 is greater than or equal to Var, the discharge tube immediately breaks down, reducing the terminal voltage to a very low level (below 10–20 V). At this point, the current through F2 increases rapidly; when it reaches 1 A, F2 blows, thereby disconnecting the hazardous high voltage and ensuring production safety.
Under normal conditions, the current and voltage fluctuations on the hazardous side are limited by R’s current-limiting function and the Zener diode’s voltage-regulating action, so F1 and F2 do not need to blow frequently.
Zener-type safety barriers are compact, lightweight, highly accurate, and widely applicable; they are also more affordable than isolating safety barriers and can achieve very high explosion-proof ratings. However, the key component of such barriers—the fast-acting fuse—poses significant manufacturing challenges, with stringent requirements for both process technology and materials. Specifically, the fusing speed of the fast-acting fuse must be at least ten times faster than the rate at which the Zener diode could be damaged by overcurrent.
Zener type Safety barrier A separate intrinsically safe grounding system is required.
Isolated safety barrier
It employs a circuit architecture that provides electrical isolation among the input, output, and power supply, while also meeting the intrinsic safety requirement for energy limitation. Although slightly more expensive than Zener-based safety solutions, its other outstanding advantages deliver greater benefits to users in practical applications:
1. Due to the adoption of a three-party isolation scheme, a system grounding conductor is not required, which greatly facilitates both design and on-site installation.
2. The instrumentation requirements for hazardous areas are significantly reduced, and isolated instruments are no longer required on-site.
3. Since the signal lines do not require a common ground, the stability and anti-interference capability of the detection and control loop signals are significantly enhanced, thereby improving the overall system reliability.
4. Isolated safety barriers offer enhanced input signal processing capabilities, enabling them to accept and process signals from thermocouples, resistance temperature detectors, frequency sensors, and other types—capabilities that Zener-type safety barriers lack.
5. Isolated safety barriers can output two mutually isolated signals, which can be supplied to two devices using the same signal source, ensuring that the signals from the two devices do not interfere with each other while enhancing the electrical safety and insulation performance between the connected devices.
Therefore, a comparison of the characteristics and performance of Zener-type and isolated safety barriers reveals that isolated safety barriers offer distinct advantages and a broader range of applications. Although their initial cost is slightly higher than that of Zener-type barriers, when considering design, construction and installation, commissioning, and maintenance costs, the total lifecycle cost may in fact be lower. In high-demand industrial environments, isolated safety barriers are almost invariably used as the primary intrinsically safe explosion-proof instrumentation; isolated Safety barrier It has gradually replaced Zener-based safety barriers and is being increasingly widely applied in the field of safety and explosion protection.